A winning merchant proposal is one page the owner can forward to a partner, an accountant, or the current processor without you in the room. It has six blocks: as-billed, proposed, delta, equipment, term, and what happens when rates move. If any block is missing, you handed them a quote, not a proposal.
- 1As-billed. Rebuild last month from the statement: volume, count, three fee layers, extras, effective rate.
- 2Proposed. Name the pricing model. Hold that same month constant. Show pass-through unchanged and the markup you are selling.
- 3Delta. Monthly dollars and the rate gap. Separate pass-through (untouched) from markup (the only layer that moved).
- 4Equipment. Buy, lease, or placement. Who holds title, the monthly cost, and what happens if they leave.
- 5Term. Initial term, auto-renew, notice window, and the exit math: ETF, liquidated damages, equipment buyout.
- 6Rate change. Who can move markup vs pass-through, with what notice. A snapshot is not a term.
As-billed: last month, not a story
Start with the month they already paid. Rebuild it the way how to read a merchant statement teaches: gross card volume, transaction count, interchange, assessments, processor markup, and every extra (PCI program, batch, statement, monthly minimum). Divide total fees by gross card volume. That is the as-billed effective rate. Net deposits are the wrong denominator: fees are already out of that number, so the rate inflates. Typical processing fees are often described as 1.5 percent to 3.5 percent of the transaction plus a per-item fee (U.S. Chamber of Commerce, 4 Jun 2026). Treat that band as typical, not as a quote. The proposal puts this merchant's month on that number line.
Worked example, illustrative. Same shop for the rest of this article: $80,000 card volume, 800 settled sales.
| Line | Amount | Layer |
|---|---|---|
| Card volume | $80,000 | |
| Transaction count | 800 | |
| Interchange | $1,360 | Pass-through |
| Assessments | $80 | Pass-through |
| Processor percentage markup | $400 | Markup |
| Per-item fees | $90 | Markup |
| Monthly extras (PCI, statement, batch) | $70 | Markup |
| Total fees | $2,000 | |
| Effective rate | 2.50% | $2,000 ÷ $80,000 |
Pass-through is $1,440 (1.80%). The negotiable stack is $560 (0.70%). If the one-pager reports 2.19% by dropping the $70 of extras, you edited the statement. Name the month on the page so a later reader can match the PDF.
Proposed: same month, named model
Hold volume, mix, and ticket constant. Name which of the six pricing models you are putting on the paper. Interchange-plus is not the default destination. Ticket size, card mix, and state law decide fit.
Show pass-through unchanged. You do not set interchange or assessments. The proposed column is the markup you are selling: percentage over cost, per-item, and monthly extras, itemized.
Continuing the illustrative month. Proposed schedule: interchange-plus 0.20% + $0.10, monthly extras $25.
| Line | As-billed | Proposed |
|---|---|---|
| Interchange | $1,360 | $1,360 |
| Assessments | $80 | $80 |
| Percentage markup | $400 | $160 (0.20% of $80,000) |
| Per-item | $90 | $80 (800 × $0.10) |
| Monthly extras | $70 | $25 |
| Total fees | $2,000 | $1,705 |
| Effective rate | 2.50% | 2.13% |
If you propose surcharge or dual pricing, the program has to be legal before it appears on the page. Visa requires 30 days of acquirer notice before a U.S. credit surcharge starts, a cap at the merchant discount rate or 3 percent (whichever is lower), disclosure at entry and the point of sale, and never on debit or prepaid (Visa merchant surcharging). Confirm state law and brand rules. Do not put an illegal model on a page an owner will forward.
Delta: dollars the owner can add up
The delta is the gap between those two totals, in money and in rate, on the same month. Here: $295 a month, 0.37 percentage points. All of it sits in markup ($560 down to $265). Pass-through did not move. Write that sentence on the page. A teaser rate cannot lower interchange.
Annualize only with a label. $295 × 12 = $3,540 if volume holds. That is a projection, illustrative, not a guarantee. A peak month is not twelve copies of itself. If you have two months, show both or show a range.
Do not compare a qualified teaser on a tiered schedule to an itemized interchange-plus markup and call the gap "savings." Those are different objects. The delta is two effective rates on one month, or it is marketing.
Equipment: title, and the second contract
A terminal is often a second contract. Put it on the same page as the rate or the owner adds the lease after they have signed.
Three shapes, none of them a market average:
- Buy. Cash price, merchant holds title. When they leave, the device can usually be reprogrammed.
- Lease. Monthly bill, often 36 or 48 months. Title usually stays with the lessor. Closing the merchant ID does not cancel the lease.
- Placement / "free." No cash at install. Read the clawback: remaining months, fair-market buyout, or a processing-volume floor that turns the gift into a payable.
Illustrative, not a quote: a $30-per-month lease on a device with a $300 cash price is $1,080 over 36 months. Next to a $295 processing delta, year-one "savings" is $3,540 minus $360 of lease, and the lessor may still bill after the processing agreement ends. Write title, monthly cost, remaining term, and buyout in one row.
Term: the clause that ends the money
The processing rate is not the agreement. The agreement is the term that stops the money. On the one-pager, in plain type:
- Initial term (month-to-month is a different object from 36 months).
- Auto-renew and the notice window that prevents a restart.
- Early termination: a flat ETF, liquidated damages (remaining months times a monthly minimum or average fees), or both.
- Whether equipment buyout stacks on top.
Walk the early termination math on the page if you are asking them to leave a live MID. A verbal "we will cover your ETF" is not a deposit. If your house will buy out a stated amount, put the cap, the payee, and the condition in writing. If you will not, do not imply it.
Illustrative only: a $495 flat ETF next to liquidated damages of remaining months times a $25 monthly minimum is two different exits. On a 36-month term with 20 months left, the formula is $500 if the greater-of clause applies. Show the formula they will actually owe.
Rate change: a snapshot is not a term
Owners forward proposals because they want to know what they will pay next April, not only last September. Split two clocks.
Pass-through. Interchange and assessments move when the networks publish schedules, commonly in April and October. Those changes flow through an interchange-plus statement whether you like them or not. You are not promising a frozen wholesale cost.
Markup. Percentage over cost, per-item, PCI program fees, statement fees, batch, and monthly minimums move only if the agreement lets the processor move them. Ask for the notice period and whether "regulatory" or "compliance" lines can be added without a new signature. A page that shows 0.20% + $0.10 and is silent on who can change it is selling a screenshot.
What the owner can actually forward
The test is mechanical. Print the page. Hand it to someone who was not in the meeting. They should be able to answer, from the paper alone:
- What did we pay last month, in dollars and as an effective rate?
- What model are we being offered, and what would that same month have cost?
- What is the monthly gap, and which layer moved?
- What do we own, lease, or return, and what does leaving cost?
- How long are we in, and who can change the number?
Assumptions live on the page: statement month, volume, count, interchange held constant, proposed extras that will actually bill. No invented shop names. No savings percentage without the two totals underneath it.
If you would rather not transcribe the as-billed month by hand, upload the PDF and take the as-billed sheet into the six blocks. The analyzer is the reconstruction. The proposal is the page that leaves the room.
What does not belong on the page
- A qualified teaser with no mid-qualified or non-qualified column.
- A savings number that omits PCI, batch, statement, or gateway lines that billed last month.
- Two different months, or net deposits used as volume.
- "Free terminal" with no title, term, or buyout.
- A three-year term described as month-to-month.
- A surcharge or dual-pricing program the merchant's state or brand rules do not allow.
The proposal that wins is the one an owner can defend after you have left. Build the six blocks. Show the arithmetic.
FAQ
What should a merchant services proposal include? Six blocks on one page: last month as billed, the proposed schedule on that same month, the dollar and rate delta, equipment title and cost, contract term and exit math, and how rates can change after you sign. If a block is missing, it is a quote, not a proposal.
What does as-billed mean on a merchant proposal? As-billed is the month the merchant actually paid: every discount, assessment, per-item, batch, PCI, and monthly extra, rebuilt from the statement before anyone quotes a cheaper model. It is the denominator for every comparison that follows.
How do I compare my current processor to a new quote? Hold one month of volume and mix constant. Compute effective rate as billed, reprice only the markup under a named model, and show the delta in dollars and percent. Do not compare a qualified teaser to an itemized interchange-plus markup, and do not switch months.
Should equipment and the processing contract be on the same proposal? Yes. A terminal lease or free placement is often a second contract that keeps billing if the merchant leaves. Put title, monthly cost, remaining term, and buyout on the same page as the rate so those dollars sit in the delta.
What happens if processing rates change after I sign? Ask who can change what, and with what notice. Interchange and assessments move on published schedules and are pass-through; markup, PCI program fees, and monthly extras are the processor's. A proposal silent on this is selling a snapshot, not a term.
Is a savings estimate the same as an effective rate? No. Effective rate is total fees divided by card volume for the same period. A savings estimate is the difference between two of those rates on a held-constant month. Annualizing one month as twelve identical months is a projection, labeled illustrative, not a guarantee.
Sources
Questions about how this applies to your business?
Talk it through